Tony Walsh, a Canadian blogger whose Clickable Culture is an excellent resource for anyone interested in the sociology of gaming, has a great post today about the pitches he gets from PR people. It’s a must-read for anyone including bloggers in their media lists, but here are a few of the great reasons he’s not writing about you:
“You have no idea what I write about”
If you’re pitching a blogger or mainstream reporter without knowing their beat, you’re not doing your job. You don’t have to know their life history, but when you’re talking to bloggers, it’s not hard to give a quick read to find out whether they write about kitchen gadgets or movies.
“You’re talking but you’re not saying anything.“
This is something that most PR people are guilty of at least a few times in their career. If you pitch something that isn’t news, or at least interesting, you’re probably wasting your time and your client’s money.
“You’ve sent me something I can’t write about yet.“
Okay, seriously. Who the hell uses embargoes anymore? Secondly, wouuld you trust a blogger not to break your embargo and spill your news early? Rookie moves.
“Is it on the record or isn’t it?“
Tony Walsh is a very nice man for asking this. Assume it’s all on the record and you reduce your chances of looking like an idiot.
“You seem to be passing yourself off as an anonymous tipster or are otherwise astroturfing.“
Another rookie move from PR people who like to pretend they’re spies. Don’t do it… you make the whole industry look bad, and yourself look like a wanker.
Walsh finishes by saying:
I’m highly cynical, jaded, crotchety, and ornery. I might discuss one or more aspects of your product, service, client and/or company that will make you unhappy. I might use framing or language you’re not comfortable with. I appreciate you want to read stories that stay “on message,” but those aren’t necessarily the stories I write (unless my views and yours happen to match).
This is a very good thing to remember. I actually did ask a blogger to change a story once, but it was because I had a very… shall we say… sensitive client and the blogger made it look like I personally had more to do with the product than the client did. While I appreciated the praise, it likely would have thrown my client into another crying fit while I was on the phone with her. It was worth it to give them the “would you mind” email to avoid that.
Again, I highly recommend Clickable Culture to anyone into online gaming, metaverse, or technological culture.